When will European politicians move from words to action? Saving the euro needs centralised fiscal supervision, a transfer mechanism, and a process for the joint and several issuance of sovereign bonds. Trichet calls this a Euro Zone “Ministry of Finance”. We often use the alternative term “federalisation”. The problem is German reluctance to take on a leadership role reflecting both their deep pockets, and their strong economy. Fear of their electorate explains why the German political leaders are so afraid to move beyond mere words. Where is the courage to spell out that the end of the euro, and a return to the Deutschmark, would mean such an increase in the exchange rate that German exports would lose much of their competitiveness, with a resultant surge in unemployment ? |
|
We still (just) retain the confidence that the words of the German political leaders will eventually lead to real action. We quote as an example the Bundesbank’s Jens Weidmann; “either we make a big jump forward to a centralised Euro Zone structure, or backwards to each country being responsible for it own finances.” The latter means no more euro. |
|
While politicians dither, markets are acting. The sub-prime crisis in the USA, where the underlying problem of spending beyond one’s means led to a banking crisis, ultimately dragged down the economy. In the Euro Zone, the incompatibility of 17 Ministries of Finance and one central bank has shown up initially as a Sovereign Debt crisis, and may, for institutions holding questionable paper, lead to a similar banking crisis, and ultimately, a similar economic outcome. It is these implications that should ultimately push the politicians into action, however it is still uncertain as to whether they are capable of taking action before Greece defaults. |
|
Only rarely do we dare comment on stock markets. We were however struck by a recent FT analysis, which compared US and Japanese stock markets in the years following the bursting of their respective bubbles. If the USA, and presumably other Western markets, follow Japan’s example, stock markets will underperform, with increased volatility, for many years to come. We were struck because this ties in so closely to our view of likely GDP growth, and our description of the recession and its aftermath as “L-shaped”. It is hard to imagine a strong stock market performance in an environment of negligible (or even negative) GDP growth, although cheap money can produce such an unlikely scenario on a temporary basis. It is however difficult to foresee what tools remain open to respective governments to cheapen the supply of money from the present position! |
|
One of our colleagues recently attended a Hong Kong conference on the Renmimbi, and the rapidly growing market for offshore bonds (“CNH”). This is all part of the unfolding move to the RMB becoming the world’s third trading and reserve currency. As HSBC state on their website, “The Chinese Renmimbi (RMB) is poised to become the world's reserve currency in the 21st century”. If rumours of Chinese participation in the Euro bailout are true, this might occur sooner than we all imagine. |
|
Next week, we will take a break from our regular Weekly to provide a more detailed summary of our present thoughts on this increasingly important topic. We shall return to our usual politico-economic commentary on 28th September. |
Market Focus |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Disclaimer |
September 14, 2011 |
Dr. Roy Damary |