Beware state guarantees

Euromoney Limited, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 15236090

4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Euromoney Limited 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Beware state guarantees

Lending to European borrowers backed by a government guarantee should be as safe as houses. But beware of the state aid rules, warns Christopher Stoakes.

Bankers with long memories will remember when a sovereign guarantee from a less developed country was regarded as safe. Then came Mexico's insolvency and the 1980s emerging-market-debt crisis. Now lenders to European borrowers are becoming vigilant - not because they are worried about borrowers' incipient insolvency, but because of EU rules governing guarantees provided by member states or state-owned entities.

Under the EC treaty, anything which threatens to distort competition between member states is deemed to be incompatible with the common market. So the provision by a member state of finance - either directly or (by way of a guarantee, for example) indirectly - can be in breach of the EC treaty and, in particular, articles 92 and 93. These cover the provision of what is called "state aid" by member states.

There is a pre-clearance procedure: basically, the member state concerned informs the European Commission, which then has a set period, usually two months, in which to respond. But this can interfere with market-driven decisions and is often honoured in the breach. Lenders tend to rely on other parties to make the necessary application, but no central record of such applications is maintained.

Gift this article