Sideways: Gas spike a canary for carbon trading PR problems

Euromoney, is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730

Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Sideways: Gas spike a canary for carbon trading PR problems



Gas price volatility is delivering profits to speculators. It is a reminder that carbon trading markets could face PR problems if energy dealers are viewed as big beneficiaries.

gas-flame-free-960.jpg

Gas prices are surging, bringing pain to consumers and profits to traders. Among the winners from record prices for products such as liquefied natural gas (LNG) has been Gunvor, the Geneva-based trading firm.

Gunvor took the opportunity of a $300 million bond launch in the last week of September to share more financial information than it has in the past.

The news was pretty good – from a trading perspective.

Gunvor’s first-half revenues doubled from the same period in 2020 to reach $48 billion, with gross profit of $642.4 million and net income of $213 million.

“LNG performed strongly, benefiting from volatility and market dislocations and the natural gas business's positive performance continued during the period,” Gunvor reported.

The recent spike in energy prices for consumers is only likely to make conversations more, well, heated

Gunvor is keen to position itself as a participant in the move to cleaner energy.

“Gunvor’s leading position in energy transition commodities, such as LNG, natural gas, and biofuels, combined with our environmental, social and governance (ESG) objectives and conservative financial management attracted solid demand from a diverse group of quality investors,” said chief financial officer Muriel Schwab, in announcing the $300 million five-year bond.

What Gunvor branded as transitional energy commodity volumes accounted for 47% of total volumes handled in the first half of 2021, the firm said.

Investors in the $300 million bond were apparently convinced by this pitch – and perhaps also by the hefty 6.25% coupon on offer.

Climate activists may be a little more sceptical about the motives and ESG credentials of a trading firm that was co-founded by oligarch Gennady Timchenko to funnel oil from Russia.

Many activists would also take issue with the branding of gas products as a transitional energy source, even though gas is cleaner than other fossil fuels.

The debate over whether or not gas should count as part of the transition to cleaner energy will continue, but the recent spike in energy prices for consumers is only likely to make conversations more, well, heated.

Carbon trading

Market dislocations that have driven up electricity prices and forced some energy providers to return to use of coal as a power source are coming at a bad time for proponents of much greater use of carbon-trading products, even if the base case for new instruments remains intact.

So-called compliance carbon markets are well established, especially in Europe.

The financial industry has high hopes for voluntary carbon trading that is not mandated by governments and could greatly expand the market for carbon offsets.

Standard Chartered chief executive Bill Winters is chairing the Taskforce on Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets, which was launched by former Bank of England governor Mark Carney.

They have gathered over 250 institutions to join the effort and enlisted an impressive advisory board of environmental specialists.

Winters has extensive practical experience of developing scale in new markets from his days at JPMorgan and is highly regarded in the financial industry.

He faces a formidable task in coordinating the diverse interests in a market that would effectively be self-regulating, however.

The current spike in gas prices does not help as it could be a harbinger of future gains for traders at the perceived expense of consumers – the market equivalent of a canary in one of the last coal mines.

Hedge funds already predict big profits from carbon trading, and oil companies with dealing divisions could also be winners from higher activity in lightly regulated markets.

Voluntary carbon trading markets could be a tough sell to ordinary citizens and politicians if they are expected to deliver large gains to hedge funds, trading firms like Gunvor or Trafigura and oil firms such as BP and Shell.


More Content Like This

The issuance of green bonds is that rare thing: a strategy on which the EU and UK agree. That is a good thing as achieving net zero will require the participation of enormous volumes of private capital.
In the final episode in this series, Marjella Lecourt-Alma, of ESG risk management specialist Datamaran, explains why she gave COP26 a miss, what she expects to be the main drivers of climate action next year, and why the quest for perfect data is a distraction from the transition challenges ahead.
As COP26 winds up, Euromoney looks at how a big reduction in fossil-fuel consumption might impact the currencies of the world’s leading coal and oil exporters.
James Close, head of climate change at NatWest, looks at how the endgame might play out in Glasgow, what promises of a net-zero finance centre in London will mean in practice and the opportunities from creating credible carbon markets.
Gift this article